Skip to content
ABD Plumbing

Why your electric water heater is tripping the breaker

Why is your electric water heater tripping the breaker? Learn the common causes, from a bad element to a faulty thermostat, and when to call a pro.

By ABD Plumbing · · 5 min read

You go to take a shower, and the water is ice cold. You check the breaker panel, and sure enough, the one for the water heater has tripped.

You reset it, but a little while later, it trips again.

That’s a workday-morning nightmare.

When an electric water heater keeps tripping the breaker, it usually points to one of a few things: a temporary overload, a tripped high-limit switch, a bad heating element, or a failing thermostat.

I’ll walk you through what you can check yourself and when you need to call a professional.

First: Turn off the power at the breaker

Before you touch your water heater, go to your home’s main electrical panel and switch the breaker for the water heater to the “off” position. We’re dealing with high-voltage electricity, and your safety is the top priority.

Step 1: Reset the circuit breaker once

Sometimes, a circuit breaker trips from a temporary power surge.

The first and simplest thing to do is to reset it.

Flip the breaker switch firmly to the “off” position, then back to “on.”

If it stays on and you get hot water again, you might have just had a one-time glitch.

However, if the breaker trips again right away, do not keep resetting it. A breaker that trips repeatedly is telling you there’s a persistent electrical fault.

Stop here and call a pro.

Step 2: Check the high-limit reset button

Your electric water heater has its own safety device called a high-limit switch. It’s designed to shut the power off if the water inside the tank gets too hot.

When this switch trips, you can usually reset it with a red button.

With the power still off at the breaker panel, find the access panels on the side of your tank. They’re usually for the upper and lower thermostats and heating elements.

After removing the panel for the upper thermostat, you should see a red button. For example, you might see it labeled “ECO” or “Reset.”

Press this button firmly until you feel or hear it click.

Then, put the access panel back on, go to your breaker box, and restore power.

If the breaker holds and you get hot water, you may have solved the problem. But a reset button that trips again is a symptom of a deeper issue, like a faulty thermostat.

Common cause 1: A bad heating element

If resetting the breaker and the high-limit switch doesn’t work, the most likely culprit is a bad heating element.

Electric water heaters have one or two of these elements to heat the water. They can wear out and develop an electrical short.

When a shorted element tries to draw power, it creates a surge that trips the breaker.

You might hear people talk about “fried wires,” and this is often what they mean.

Testing and replacing a heating element involves working directly with the unit’s high-voltage wiring, so this is a job for a licensed plumber.

Common cause 2: A faulty thermostat

The thermostats control the heating elements, telling them when to turn on and off to maintain the water temperature.

If a thermostat gets stuck in the “on” position, it can cause the water to overheat. That in turn trips the high-limit safety switch we talked about earlier.

While this trips the reset button more often than the main breaker, a failing thermostat can also cause electrical issues that lead to a trip.

Diagnosing a bad thermostat requires specific tools and knowledge.

A quick guide to DIY vs. pro repairs

Here’s a quick summary of what to do.

Symptom Your next step
Breaker tripped once DIY: Reset it once.
Breaker trips repeatedly Pro: Call for service.
High-limit switch tripped DIY: Press the reset button once.
High-limit switch trips repeatedly Pro: Call for service.
Suspected bad element or thermostat Pro: Call for service.

When to call a professional for help

You should call a professional if:

  • The circuit breaker trips immediately after you reset it.
  • The red high-limit reset button on the water heater keeps tripping.
  • You suspect a problem with a heating element or thermostat.
  • You see any signs of corrosion, leaks, or damaged wiring around the access panels.

Anything that involves taking apart components or working with the electrical connections is a job for a professional. It’s safer, and a pro will make sure they do the repair correctly. If you’re facing any of these issues, give ABD Plumbing a call. We can diagnose the problem and explain your options for a water heater repair.

One rule to follow after any water heater repair

Here’s a piece of advice I give every homeowner.

If you or a plumber ever has to drain your water heater tank for a repair, like replacing an element, there’s one critical step. Never restore power to the unit until the tank is completely full of water again.

Powering on an electric water heater with a dry tank will burn out the new heating element in seconds.

I’ve seen it happen.

It turns a simple fix into another service call.

Always run a hot water tap somewhere in the house and wait until water flows freely before you flip that breaker back on.

If your water heater is giving you trouble, give us a call. We’re open Monday to Friday, 8am to 8pm, and weekends by appointment.

More plumbing advice

· 6 min read

What is an atmospheric vent water heater?

What is an atmospheric vent water heater? Learn how this common gas water heater works, how it differs from other types, and if it's right for your home.

Request a plumber in Huntsville

Send the details and we'll call you back to set a time. If water is running where it shouldn't, calling is faster.

Faster by phone

(256) 221-2847 Mon–Fri 8am–8pm

(256) 221-2847 Mon–Fri 8am–8pm